Nancy DeKalb

June 9, 2006

A Good Read Ruined

Filed under: Blogroll — Nancy DeKalb @ 11:42 am

It’s fiction. It says so right on the spine of the book, above the title, The Da Vinci Code.

It’s meant to be nothing more than a good read that causes you to pause occasionally after reading a passage and think, “gee, I should take another look at that masterpiece by Leonardo Da Vinci.”

Why is it that anytime a good read is published, there’s an outcry that the book is going to destroy our faith, encourage bad behavior or corrupt us in other ways. The latest is The Da Vinci Code. Before that it was the Harry Potter series and Harry Potter was preceded by To Kill a Mockingbird and C.S. Lewis books. Fiction is a great escape — transporting the reader to other lands and lives – until marketing muddies the water.

Positive word-of-mouth marketing can land a book on The New York Times bestseller list and get it adopted as a must-read for book clubs. Equally positive (or negative, as is the case here) grassroots advocacy can cause a book to be bashed from the pulpit and on the op-ed pages of the national and local newspapers. The positive buzz can quickly turn to negative and confuse fiction with fact.

The fact is … it’s fiction … fiction that has encouraged people to turn away from the TV and turn another page in the book. It’s fiction that has encouraged lunchroom discussions among co-workers and conversations with friends and family. That’s what a good read is all about.

1 Comment »

  1. Nancy, As an avid Harry Potter fan, I agree with you about fiction. A good read is a real joy and a fabulous vacation for the mind. But here’s the catch. Really good fiction is always, at some level, based on a deeper truth, truth of fact maybe, or truth of feeling,maybe even a truth we don’t want to admit to or think about. And gets people riled.
    Ok, so having said that I have to consider what the truth is within Harry Potter that has roused so much resistance. Is the idea of a wizard, a power we don’t understand, threatening because it contains truth. The truth that we don’t know how much we don’t know? Well, OK, that is scary. Maybe R J Rawlings’ publisher should hire KVB to take on this issue!

    Comment by amy lynch — August 27, 2007 @ 3:10 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

 

Powered by WordPress